Justia Public Benefits Opinion Summaries

Plaintiff, on her child's behalf, applied for survivorship benefits under the Social Security Act where the child was conceived by in vitro fertilization after the child's biological father, plaintiff's husband, passed away a number of years before the child was conceived. At issue was whether natural children, such as plaintiff's child, plainly fell within 42 U.S.C. 416(e)(1)'s basic definition of "child," and therefore making their intestacy rights irrelevant. The court held that the Social Security Administration's denial of survivorship benefits best reflected the statute's text, structure, and aim of providing primarily to those who unexpectedly lose a wage earner's support and that this view fell well within the range of permissible readings entitled to deference under Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council.